Current Events and the Psychology of Politics
Loading

Featured Posts        



categories        



Links        



archives        



meta        




Mar 20th, 2009


Can We Bail Out of the Bailouts?

What if we let companies that are ‘too big to fail’ do just that?

Image: Women walk in front of the AIG building in Tokyo
The AIG building in Tokyo, Japan. (Photo credit: Shizuo Kambayashi / AP)


March 19, 2009

NEW YORK — What if the U.S. government got out of the bailout business?

The idea certainly seemed all right with throngs of Americans who were outraged by news that American International Group paid out millions of dollars in executive bonuses after it was rescued with taxpayer cash.

But would no bailout be even worse? Financial analysts and federal officials have warned that doing nothing to save AIG — or banks or the auto industry — would be a catastrophe, an economic domino effect of bank losses, stock market chaos and job cuts. No one — at least no one in the government — has the stomach for that.

Here’s what might happen if companies deemed “too big to fail” were allowed to do just that.

Not bailing out American International Group

For bailout backlash, it’s hard to beat AIG. The government has made four separate loans and cash infusions to the crippled insurer, including $30 billion earlier this month. Total tab: $170 billion.

Public outrage reached new heights when word spread that AIG had paid executives $165 million in bonuses. President Barack Obama ordered his treasury secretary to grab back what he could, and one senator even suggested the recipients kill themselves.

So why not pull the plug? Because AIG has 74 million customers and operates in 130 countries, and letting it implode would positively unhinge financial markets around the world.

AIG built a murky, unregulated business issuing insurance for mortgage-backed securities and other debt held by banks. When the housing bubble popped and those securities went bad, AIG was left on the hook for billions of dollars in claims it couldn’t pay.

Letting AIG die would make all of that insurance worthless. Banks around the world would be forced to take massive losses. Some could collapse, unnerving markets, driving up unemployment and maybe turning the recession into a depression.

The U.S. got a taste of that scenario in September, when bad debt forced investment bank Lehman Brothers into the biggest bankruptcy in U.S. history. Thousands of other firms were exposed to Lehman’s complex financial contracts, and the resulting fear and uncertainty sent stocks plunging.

And that was just a small taste.

“AIG is about five times bigger than Lehman Brothers, and we learned that Lehman Brothers should not have gone bankrupt,” said Mark T. Williams, professor of finance and economics at Boston University and a former Federal Reserve bank examiner. …

AIG itself has predicted nothing short of a financial apocalypse unless it stays on government life support.

In a bleak report to the Treasury Department late last month, AIG said its collapse could batter credit markets, bankrupt the U.S. insurance industry, depress the dollar, increase U.S. borrowing costs and shatter consumer and business confidence everywhere.

“The failure of AIG,” the company warns in the report, “would cause turmoil in the U.S. economy and global markets, and have multiple and potentially catastrophic unforeseen consequences.”

“What happens to AIG has the potential to trigger a cascading set of further failures which cannot be stopped except by extraordinary means,” the report adds.

Not everyone buys the doomsday scenario.

Some critics, including billionaire investor Jim Rogers, say keeping the company on the public dole is ruining the U.S. economy. …

The government says letting AIG fail simply is not an option.

Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke, speaking to legislators earlier this month, warned that the damage to the world economy of an AIG failure would run into the “multiples of trillions.” …

Read more:

Not bailing out the banks

Not bailing out the automakers





2 Responses to “Should We Turn Our Back on AIG?”
  1. Immelman for Congress » Blog Archive » AfPak Foreign Policy Success Says:

    […] Should We Turn Our Back on AIG? […]

  2. Immelman for Congress » Blog Archive » Gadhafi Suffers Heavy Losses Says:

    […] Should We Turn Our Back on AIG? […]

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.